Struggling to find a mattress that’s soft yet supportive? The wrong choice could leave you tossing and turning, waking up with backaches or sore shoulders. Without the right mattress, you might face restless nights and tired mornings, which can disrupt your entire day. That’s where the best soft mattress comes in to save the day and your sleep.

This article covers the best soft mattresses designed to provide comfort while addressing common issues like pressure points, overheating, and lack of proper support. Whether you’re a side sleeper who needs cushioning for your shoulders or someone who overheats at night, the options here are built to enhance your sleep experience.

By exploring this guide, you’ll discover mattresses with advanced features like cooling layers, durable materials, and plush comfort, all backed by strong warranties and trial periods. Say goodbye to restless nights and hello to a mattress that helps you wake up refreshed and ready to tackle your day.

Key Takeaways

  • The hybrid design of the Helix Sunset Luxe includes memory foam and zoned coils that help ease pressure on shoulders and hips.
  • The soft Euro topper and breathable foams in Nolah Evolution 15″ help side sleepers stay cool and comfortable while easing pressure on joints.
  • Couples will like the Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid for its soft feel, strong edge support, and coils that limit motion transfer.
  • The Bear Elite Hybrid uses a five-zone coil system and memory foam to relieve back pain and keep the mattress cool all night.
  • The Puffy Lux Mattress is a great choice for hot sleepers with its cooling foam and plush comfort that work well for side and back sleeping.
Helix Sunset Luxe
AUTHOR

Mattress Advisory

CATEGORY

Best Mattress

POSTED ON

March 03, 2024

Helix

Helix Sunset Luxe

Credits: Helix

Helix Sunset Luxe

A premium soft hybrid mattress featuring pressure-relieving foams and enhanced zoned lumbar support.

Nolah

Nolah Evolution 15

Credits: Nolah

Nolah Evolution 15″

A luxury model featuring a plush Euro topper, soothing foams, and tri-zoned support.

Brooklyn Bedding

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

A hybrid mattress featuring Variflex compression support and supreme response comfort foam.

Bear

Bear Elite Hybrid

Credits: Bear

Bear Elite Hybrid

An ultra-luxurious 14-inch mattress with an advanced cooling technology and five zone support coil system.

Puffy

Puffy Lux Mattress

Credits: Puffy

Puffy Lux Mattress

An ultra luxury hybrid mattress that balances support, ultra-responsive body contouring, and softness.

Helix Sunset Luxe

Credits: Helix

Helix Sunset Luxe

A premium soft hybrid mattress featuring pressure-relieving foams and enhanced zoned lumbar support.

Nolah Evolution 15"

Credits: Nolah

Nolah Evolution 15″

A luxury model featuring a plush Euro topper, soothing foams, and tri-zoned support.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

Credits: Brooklyn Bedding

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

A hybrid mattress featuring Variflex compression support and supreme response comfort foam.

Bear Elite Hybrid

Credits: Bear

Bear Elite Hybrid

An ultra-luxurious 14-inch mattress with an advanced cooling technology and five zone support coil system.

Puffy Lux Mattress

Credits: Helix

Helix Dusk Luxe

A luxury model featuring a plush Euro topper, soothing foams, and tri-zoned support.

An Expert And Helpful Guide To Help You Find The Best Soft Mattress

Best Soft Mattress

A premium soft hybrid mattress featuring pressure-relieving foams and enhanced zoned lumbar support.

Helix Sunset Luxe

Credits: Helix

Who It’s Best For

The Helix Sunset Luxe is the best soft mattress for side and back sleepers who love plush comfort without losing support. Its 13.5-inch profile combines soft Helix Responsive Foam and Copper Gel Memory Foam for pressure relief, while individually wrapped coils add targeted support and excellent motion isolation.

This mattress is perfect for those under 300 lbs who struggle with shoulder or hip pain caused by firmer beds. It’s also a great choice for anyone who overheats during the night, thanks to its cooling TENCEL or GlacioTex cover. If restful, supportive sleep is a priority, this mattress is a no-brainer.

Who It’s Not The Best For

The Helix Sunset Luxe, while the best soft mattress for many, isn’t the right pick for those who need extra firmness or support for heavier weights. Sleepers over 300 lbs may find the mattress too soft and should consider a firmer option like the Helix Plus Luxe.

If you’re a stomach sleeper who prefers a more supportive feel, this mattress might not keep your spine aligned. Additionally, it’s not designed to fix issues caused by extremely firm or unsupportive foundations, so upgrading your bed frame might be necessary for a truly comfortable experience.

“I went with the sunset luxe! Been about 3ish weeks now and so far so good. I’d been having arm pain and it’s basically gone.”

u/congratsonyosuccess, Reddit

What It’s Made Of

The Helix Sunset Luxe combines premium materials for comfort and support. The top layer features Helix Responsive Foam and Copper Gel Memory Foam, which contour to your body, relieve pressure, and keep you cool at night. Beneath that, individually wrapped coils enhance support and reduce motion transfer, making it great for couples.

The mattress is finished with a breathable TENCEL cover or an optional GlacioTex Cooling Cover to regulate temperature. Together, these materials deliver plush comfort, superior pressure relief, and a cool, restful sleep experience.

Mattress Specifications

Helix

Hybrid (Memory Foam and Coils)

13.5 Inches (High Profile)

Soft (3.5 out of 10)

Side and Back Sleepers

250 to 300 lbs. (Per Sleeper. See Helix Plus Luxe for Additional Weight Support)

Helix Responsive Foam or ErgoAlign Contour Foam and Copper Gel Memory Foam

Helix Responsive Foam and Individually Wrapped Coils

Excellent

Premium Cooling Pillow Top with Breathable TENCEL Cover or GlacioTex Cooling Cover

100 Nights

Lifetime Warranty

Free Shipping

Free

Shop Pay, PayPal, and Affirm

Why It’s The Best Soft Mattress Overall

The Helix Sunset Luxe earns its title as the best soft mattress by combining plush comfort with strong support. Its memory foam layers ease pressure on your hips and shoulders, while individually wrapped coils provide stability and reduce motion transfer.

This mattress solves common sleep issues like overheating, restless tossing, and discomfort from firm beds. Its cooling covers and responsive materials make it a great pick for side and back sleepers looking for a cozy, cloud-like feel. If you want better sleep and all-night comfort, the Helix Sunset Luxe is an excellent choice.

Helix
Check Price

Helix Sunset Luxe

A premium soft hybrid mattress featuring pressure-relieving foams and enhanced zoned lumbar support.
Check Price

Helix Sunset Luxe

A premium soft hybrid mattress featuring pressure-relieving foams and enhanced zoned lumbar support.
Check Price

A luxury model featuring a plush Euro topper, soothing foams, and tri-zoned support.

Nolah Evolution 15"

Credits: Nolah

Who It’s Best For

The Nolah Evolution 15″ is the best soft mattress for side sleepers who want pressure relief and a cool night’s sleep. Its plush Euro topper and breathable AirFoam cushion your shoulders and hips, easing pressure points and promoting proper spinal alignment.

This mattress is perfect for side sleepers experiencing hip or shoulder discomfort and back sleepers who love a softer feel. It also works for couples due to its excellent motion isolation. With advanced cooling features like the ArcticTex cover and heat-escape gussets, it solves overheating issues. If comfort and support are what you need, this mattress delivers.

Who It’s Not The Best For

The Nolah Evolution 15″ might not work for sleepers who prefer an ultra-firm surface or need support for weights exceeding 300 lbs. The plush version could feel too soft for stomach sleepers who need extra firmness to keep their spine aligned.

If you’re looking for a firmer option, the luxury firm or firm versions may suit you better. For additional weight support, the Nolah Evolution Comfort+ is a smarter choice. This mattress also won’t resolve discomfort caused by an unsuitable bed base, so ensure your foundation is sturdy and supportive for the best sleep experience.

“I sleep better on this than I have on other mattresses in the past and it has a nice amount of give/sinking into feeling coupled with good support.”

r/Mattress, Reddit

What It’s Made Of

The Nolah Evolution 15″ combines premium materials for comfort, cooling, and support. Its Cooling Quilted Euro Topper and AirFoam contour to your body, relieving pressure on shoulders and hips while staying breathable.

The HDMax Tri-Zone Coils deliver targeted support for your back and excellent edge stability. Beneath that, CoreComfort Foam and EverAdapt Transition Foam provide added cushioning and a smooth feel. An ArcticTex cover and AirBreath gusset keep the mattress cool by promoting airflow. Together, these materials offer plush comfort, proper alignment, and a cool, restful sleep experience.

Mattress Specifications

Nolah

Hybrid (Memory Foam and Coils)

15 Inches (High Profile)

Plush (4.5 out of 10), Luxury Firm (5.5 out of 10), and Firm (7.5 out of 10)

Side, Back, and Stomach Sleepers

250 to 300 lbs. (Per Sleeper. See Nolah Evolution Comfort+ for Additional Weight Support)

Cooling Quilted Euro Topper and Zoned AirFoam

CoreComfort Foam, EverAdapt Transition Foam, and HDMAx Tri-Zone Coils

Organic Cotton + ArticTex Cover, Cooling Quilted Euro Topper, Breathable AirFoam, and AirBreath Heat Escape Gusset

120 Nights

Lifetime Warranty

Free Shipping

$99 Processing Fee

Shop Pay, PayPal, and Affirm

Why It’s The Best Soft Mattress for Side Sleepers

The Nolah Evolution 15″ earns its title as the best soft mattress for side sleepers by combining plush comfort with exceptional support. Its AirFoam and Euro Topper relieve pressure on shoulders and hips, while HDMax Tri-Zone Coils keep your spine aligned.

This mattress solves common sleep problems like joint pain and overheating. The ArcticTex cover and breathable gussets keep you cool, while the advanced layers reduce motion transfer, making it great for couples. If you want a luxurious, supportive mattress for pressure-free, restful nights, the Nolah Evolution 15″ is a perfect choice.

Nolah
Check Price

Nolah Evolution 15”

A luxury model featuring a plush Euro topper, soothing foams, and tri-zoned support.
Check Price

Nolah Evolution 15”

A luxury model featuring a plush Euro topper, soothing foams, and tri-zoned support.
Check Price

A hybrid mattress featuring Variflex compression support and supreme response comfort foam.

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

Who It’s Best For

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid is the best value soft mattress for side sleepers who need pressure relief and couples who appreciate motion isolation. Its soft (3/10) firmness and Supreme Response Comfort Foam cushion pressure points, while the Ascension Coils offer support and reduce motion transfer.

This mattress is a great fit for side sleepers experiencing shoulder or hip discomfort and back or stomach sleepers who prefer medium or firm options. Its cooling quilted top prevents overheating, solving common sleep issues. If you want luxury comfort at an affordable price, this mattress is a top contender.

Who It’s Not The Best For

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid, while the best value soft mattress, isn’t the best choice for sleepers over 300 lbs who need extra support. For heavier individuals, the Titan Plus offers more durability and firmness.

If you prefer an ultra-firm mattress or dislike the responsive feel of a hybrid design, this may not suit your needs. Additionally, this mattress won’t fix issues caused by an unsupportive bed frame, so ensure your foundation is sturdy. Choosing the right fit ensures you get the comfort and support you’re after.

“I sleep better on this than I have on other mattresses in the past and it has a nice amount of give/sinking into feeling coupled with good support.”

u/TheApprenticeLife, Reddit

What It’s Made Of

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid combines high-quality materials for comfort and support. Its premium quilted top adds a soft, plush feel while helping regulate temperature. The Supreme Response Comfort Foam cushions pressure points, easing discomfort in your hips and shoulders.

VariFlex Transition Foam creates a smooth layer that prevents sinking, and the Ascension Coils provide targeted support and reduce motion transfer, perfect for couples. Together, these materials deliver a comfortable, supportive, and cool sleeping surface that adapts to your needs for a restful night.

Mattress Specifications

Brooklyn Bedding

Hybrid (Memory Foam and Coils)

12.25 Inches (High Profile)

Soft (3 out of 10), Medium (5 out of 10), and Firm (7 out of 10)

Side, Back, and Stomach Sleepers

250 to 300 lbs. (Per Sleeper. See Titan Plus for Additional Weight Support)

Premium Quilted Top and Supreme Response Comfort Foam
VariFlex Transition Foam and Ascension Individually Encased Coils

Premium Quilted Top

120 Nights

Lifetime Warranty

Free Shipping

$99 Processing Fee

Shop Pay, PayPal, and Affirm

Why It’s The Best Value Soft Mattress

The Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid offers premium features at an affordable price, earning its accolade as the best value soft mattress. Its plush quilted top, Supreme Response Comfort Foam, and Ascension Coils provide pressure relief, support, and cooling.

This mattress solves common sleep problems like joint pain, overheating, and motion transfer, making it a top choice for side sleepers and couples. With its durability, comfort, and free shipping, it’s a great investment for anyone wanting a luxurious sleep experience without spending a fortune. Perfect for restful, rejuvenating nights.

Brooklyn Bedding
Check Price

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

A premium hybrid mattress that features an individually wrapped spring system and premium foams.
Check Price

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

A premium hybrid mattress that features an individually wrapped spring system and premium foams.
Check Price

An ultra-luxurious 14-inch mattress with an advanced cooling technology and five zone support coil system.

Bear Elite Hybrid

Credits: Bear

Who It’s Best For

The Bear Elite Hybrid is the best soft mattress for back pain, designed to combine comfort and targeted support. Its copper-infused memory foam relieves pressure, while the five-zone coil system supports your spine and reduces strain.

This mattress is perfect for back and side sleepers dealing with lower back pain or pressure in the hips and shoulders. The cooling Celliant cover and PCM Quilted Tight Top ensure a cool, comfortable sleep. It solves issues like poor spinal alignment and restless nights, offering a soft, supportive surface that helps you wake up feeling refreshed and pain-free.

Who It’s Not The Best For

The Bear Elite Hybrid may not suit individuals over 300 lbs or those who prefer an ultra-firm sleeping surface. Its soft (5/10) feel is designed for pressure relief, but heavier sleepers might require a more supportive option like the Titan Plus.

This mattress also won’t resolve issues caused by an uneven or unsupportive bed frame, so ensure your foundation is sturdy. If you dislike the responsive feel of hybrid mattresses, an all-foam design might be a better choice. For everyone else, this is the best soft mattress for back pain relief and restful sleep.

“I’m still really happy with my purchase. I sleep great and have significantly less back pain than I had with my previous mattress.”

u/FelixFelicis117, Reddit

What It’s Made Of

The Bear Elite Hybrid combines advanced materials to deliver comfort and support. The PCM Cooling Quilted Tight Top and copper-infused memory foam relieve pressure while keeping you cool throughout the night. Dynamic Transition Foam adds a cushioning layer, ensuring smooth support between the foam and the five-zone coil system. 

These coils provide targeted support for your back and excellent motion isolation, so you won’t feel your partner move. With its cooling and ergonomic design, this mattress helps alleviate back pain while creating a soft, supportive sleep surface.

Mattress Specifications

Bear

Hybrid (Memory Foam and Coils)

14 Inches (High Profile)

Soft (5 out of 10), Medium (6 out of 10), and Firm (7 out of 10)

Side, Back, and Stomach Sleepers

250 to 300 lbs. (Per Sleeper. See Titan Plus for Additional Weight Support)

PCM Cooling Quilted Tight Top and Copper-Infused Memory Foam

Dynamic Transition Foam and Five-Zone Support Coil System + Reinforced Edge Coils

Excellent

Celliant Fiber, PCM Cooling Quilted Tight Top, and Copper-Infused Memory Foam

120 Nights

Lifetime Warranty

Free Shipping

Shop Pay, PayPal, and Affirm

Why It’s The Best Soft Mattress for Back Pain

The Bear Elite Hybrid is the best soft mattress for back pain, combining copper-infused memory foam and a five-zone coil system to relieve pressure and support spinal alignment. Its cooling features, like the PCM Quilted Tight Top, ensure you sleep comfortably without overheating.

This mattress addresses common back pain triggers such as poor alignment and insufficient support. The soft yet supportive feel cushions sensitive areas while maintaining proper posture. For anyone struggling with discomfort or restless nights, this mattress offers a solution that promotes restful, pain-free sleep and a refreshed morning.

Bear
Check Price

Bear Elite Hybrid

An ultra-luxurious 14-inch mattress with an advanced cooling technology and five zone support coil system.
Check Price

Bear Elite Hybrid

An ultra-luxurious 14-inch mattress with an advanced cooling technology and five zone support coil system.
Check Price

An ultra luxury hybrid mattress that balances support, ultra-responsive body contouring, and softness.

Puffy Lux Mattress

Credits: Puffy

Who It’s Best For

The Puffy Lux Mattress is the best soft cooling mattress for side and back sleepers who enjoy plush comfort. Its medium-plush feel (6.5/10) cushions pressure points while the Contour Adapt Coils support your spine.

This mattress is perfect for hot sleepers, with its Cooling Cloud Foam and Cool Touch Quilted Cloud Cover keeping you cool all night. If you struggle with overheating or discomfort in your shoulders and hips, this mattress solves those issues. It offers a soft, refreshing sleep environment that ensures restful nights and comfortable mornings.

Who It’s Not The Best For

The Puffy Lux Mattress may not suit stomach sleepers or those over 300 lbs who need extra firmness for proper support. Its medium-plush feel might not provide the stability these sleepers require.

For heavier individuals, the Puffy Monarch Mattress offers greater durability and support. Additionally, this mattress won’t resolve issues caused by an unsupportive bed frame, so ensure your foundation is sturdy. If you prefer an ultra-firm surface, this mattress might feel too soft, but for most sleepers, it’s the best soft cooling mattress for a comfortable night.

“Had my Puffy Lux for about eight months now. As a side sleeper, it’s been pretty comfy. Took a week to get used to it. I’m a restless sleeper, but I’m tossing and turning less now.”

u/No-Respond2221, Reddit

What It’s Made Of

The Puffy Lux Mattress features layers designed for comfort and cooling. The Cool Touch Quilted Cloud Cover and Climate Fiber Layer wick away heat, while Cooling Cloud Foam keeps the surface temperature regulated.

Plush Dual Cloud Foam relieves pressure on shoulders and hips, making it great for side and back sleepers. Beneath that, Contour Adapt Coils provide targeted support and excellent motion isolation. Together, these materials create a soft, breathable, and supportive mattress that helps you sleep cool and wake up refreshed.

Mattress Specifications

Puffy

Hybrid (Memory Foam and Coils)

12 Inches (High Profile)

Medium-Plush (6.5 out of 10)

Side and Back Sleepers

250 to 300 lbs. (Per Sleeper. See Puffy Monarch Mattress for Additional Weight Support)

Cooling Cloud Foam and Plush Dual Cloud Foam

Cloud Comfort Pressure Relief Foam and Contour Adapt Coils

Cool Touch Quilted Cloud Cover, Climate Fiber Layer, and Cooling Cloud Foam

1o1 Nights

Lifetime Warranty

Free Shipping

Free

Shop Pay, PayPal, and Affirm

Why It’s The Best Soft Cooling Mattress

The Puffy Lux Mattress earns its accolade as the best soft cooling mattress by combining plush comfort with advanced cooling technology. Its Cooling Cloud Foam and quilted cover help prevent overheating, while the Plush Dual Cloud Foam relieves pressure on sensitive areas like shoulders and hips.

This mattress solves issues like restless nights caused by heat and discomfort from poor support. With its medium-plush feel and Contour Adapt Coils for stability, it’s a great choice for side and back sleepers who want a cooler, more restful sleep experience. Perfect for waking up refreshed every morning.

Puffy
Check Price

Puffy Lux Mattress

An ultra luxury hybrid mattress that balances support, ultra-responsive body contouring, and softness.
Check Price

Puffy Lux Mattress

An ultra luxury hybrid mattress that balances support, ultra-responsive body contouring, and softness.
Check Price

More on the Best Soft Mattress

Things To Consider When Looking For The Best Soft Mattress

Weight

Your weight plays a big role in how a soft mattress feels. Lighter sleepers often enjoy softer mattresses as they provide enough contouring and pressure relief. Heavier sleepers, however, might find a soft mattress too plush, which could lead to improper spinal alignment or sagging.
If you’re on the heavier side but still want a soft feel, a hybrid model with strong coils for support can provide the comfort and stability you need.

Sleeping Position

Side Sleeper

Side sleepers benefit most from a soft or medium mattress. These options cushion pressure points like shoulders and hips while keeping the spine aligned.
If you’re a side sleeper looking for a bit more support, a medium mattress might work better. It offers a balance between contouring and firmness, ensuring comfort without compromising posture during the night.

Back Sleeper

Back sleepers can enjoy the comfort of the best soft mattress if it provides the right balance of contouring and support. A mattress that’s too soft might cause the lower back to sink, leading to discomfort or strain.

To prevent this, look for a soft mattress with supportive layers like memory foam or a hybrid design featuring coils. These materials help keep your spine aligned while cushioning pressure points, ensuring you wake up without back pain. A medium-soft mattress can also work well, combining plush comfort with enough firmness to support your lower back.

Stomach Sleeper

Stomach sleepers often need a mattress with firmer support to prevent their hips from sinking too deeply, which can strain the lower back. The best soft mattress for stomach sleepers should have a soft top layer for comfort but a firmer core for proper alignment. Hybrid models with reinforced coils or dense foam layers can provide the plush feel you want without sacrificing support, helping to reduce back and neck discomfort.

Combination Sleeper

Combination sleepers, who change positions during the night, need a mattress that adapts to different sleeping styles. The best soft mattress for these sleepers should provide a soft, contouring surface for side sleeping, with enough support for back and stomach positions. A hybrid or memory foam mattress with responsive layers works well, offering both comfort and flexibility to keep you comfortable no matter how you move.

On-Edge Sleeper

If you tend to sleep near the edge of your bed, the best soft mattress should have strong edge support to prevent sagging or the feeling that you might roll off. Hybrid mattresses with reinforced edge coils are a great option, as they provide both comfort and stability. This feature is especially important for couples or those who use the entire mattress surface. A soft mattress with good edge support ensures you feel secure and supported, even when sleeping close to the edge.

Helix
Check Price

Helix Sunset Luxe

A premium soft hybrid mattress featuring pressure-relieving foams and enhanced zoned lumbar support.
Check Price

Helix Sunset Luxe

A premium soft hybrid mattress featuring pressure-relieving foams and enhanced zoned lumbar support.
Check Price

Material

The materials in the best soft mattress affect its comfort, durability, and cooling ability. Memory foam mattresses are great for pressure relief and contouring but can retain heat. Gel-infused foam or hybrid models with cooling technologies offer a cooler sleep experience.

Latex provides a responsive, breathable surface, while innerspring or hybrid mattresses deliver extra support and durability. Choosing the right materials ensures a mattress that suits your needs and enhances your sleep quality.

Mattress Type

Memory Foam

Memory foam is a popular choice for the best soft mattress because it contours closely to your body, relieving pressure on joints like shoulders and hips. This material is especially good for side sleepers or those who need extra cushioning.

However, traditional memory foam can trap heat, so look for mattresses with gel-infused foam or cooling layers if you’re a hot sleeper. Memory foam provides a cradling feel that minimizes motion transfer, making it great for couples who want uninterrupted sleep.

Latex

Latex mattresses are a great option for the best soft mattress because they combine comfort with responsiveness. They contour to your body like memory foam but have a bouncier feel, making it easier to move around during sleep. Latex is naturally breathable, which helps keep you cool at night. It’s also durable, so your mattress will maintain its softness and support for years. If you’re looking for a soft yet supportive surface that stays cool, latex is worth considering.

Organic

If you want an eco-friendly option for the best soft mattress, an organic mattress is a top choice. These mattresses often use natural materials like organic cotton, wool, and latex, which are free of harmful chemicals and safe for sensitive sleepers.  Organic mattresses are also naturally breathable, which helps regulate temperature for a cool and comfortable night. They’re a great choice for those who value sustainability and want a clean, soft sleep surface.

Innerspring

An innerspring mattress can be a contender for the best soft mattress if it includes a plush comfort layer. These mattresses use a network of coils for support, giving them a springy and responsive feel. The soft top layer, often made of foam or pillow-top material, adds cushioning for pressure relief.

Innerspring models are breathable, allowing heat to escape for a cooler sleep. They’re a great choice for sleepers who prefer the classic bounce of a traditional mattress with a soft surface for added comfort.

Hybrid

A hybrid mattress combines the best features of foam and innerspring designs, making it a top pick for the best soft mattress. The foam layers offer pressure relief and contouring, while the innerspring coils provide support and durability.

Hybrids often include cooling features like gel-infused foam or breathable covers, making them perfect for hot sleepers. With a hybrid mattress, you get the softness you want and the support you need, making it a versatile option for various sleep positions and preferences.

Nolah
Check Price

Nolah Evolution 15”

A luxury model featuring a plush Euro topper, soothing foams, and tri-zoned support.
Check Price

Nolah Evolution 15”

A luxury model featuring a plush Euro topper, soothing foams, and tri-zoned support.
Check Price

Support

The best soft mattress should offer comfort without sacrificing support. Support keeps your spine aligned while you sleep, preventing discomfort and back pain. Even in a soft mattress, high-quality support layers, like reinforced coils or dense foam, ensure your body stays properly positioned.

Side sleepers may need softer cushioning for pressure points, but it’s still important to have a sturdy base to prevent sinking too much. Support helps maintain a healthy posture, no matter your preferred sleep position.

Firmness Level

Soft

A soft mattress is perfect for those who love a plush, cushioning feel. It typically rates between 3 and 4 on a firmness scale and is great for the best soft mattress experience. Side sleepers benefit most from this level of softness, as it reduces pressure on shoulders and hips. However, lighter sleepers across all positions may also find comfort on a soft mattress. To avoid sinking too much, ensure the mattress has a supportive base, such as high-density foam or coils.

Medium-Soft

A medium-soft mattress offers a slightly firmer feel than a soft one, making it a versatile choice for the best soft mattress option. It scores around 4 to 5 on a firmness scale, providing enough plushness for side sleepers while supporting back or combination sleepers. This firmness level works well for those who enjoy a softer feel but need a bit more structure to keep their spine aligned and avoid discomfort during the night.

Medium

A medium mattress hits the sweet spot between soft and firm, making it a great choice for many sleepers. It’s not as plush as the best soft mattress, but it still offers a cozy, slightly cushioned feel. Side sleepers who want more support and back sleepers who like a touch of softness love medium mattresses. It keeps your spine aligned while relieving pressure, so you wake up feeling refreshed instead of achy.

Medium-Firm

Medium-firm mattresses are a bit firmer than medium ones but still have enough comfort to feel cozy. They’re great for back and stomach sleepers who need more support to keep their hips and spine in the right position. If you love the comfort of a soft surface but don’t want to feel like you’re sinking too much, a medium-firm mattress gives you that supportive lift with just the right touch of cushioning.

Firm

A firm mattress offers the most support, with little to no sink-in feel. It’s a great choice for stomach sleepers or heavier individuals who need extra stability to keep their hips and spine aligned. While it’s not the same as the best soft mattress, a firm option ensures your body stays supported and prevents pressure buildup. If you’re someone who wakes up with back pain on softer beds, a firm mattress might be the solution to keep you comfortable and ache-free.

Brooklyn Bedding
Check Price

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

A premium hybrid mattress that features an individually wrapped spring system and premium foams.
Check Price

Brooklyn Bedding Signature Hybrid

A premium hybrid mattress that features an individually wrapped spring system and premium foams.
Check Price

Breathability

When choosing the best soft mattress, breathability is important for a cool and restful sleep. Materials like gel-infused foam, open-cell latex, or hybrid designs with coils allow airflow to prevent heat buildup.  A breathable mattress keeps you from waking up hot and sweaty, making it perfect for warm climates or naturally hot sleepers. Look for features like moisture-wicking covers or cooling layers to ensure your mattress helps regulate temperature all night.

Temperature Regulation

Cooling Cover

A cooling cover is a great feature to look for when choosing the best soft mattress, especially if you tend to sleep hot. These covers are designed to wick away heat and moisture, helping you stay cool throughout the night.

Materials like breathable cotton, moisture-wicking fibers, or even advanced cooling fabrics like phase-change material work to regulate your temperature. It’s like having built-in air conditioning for your mattress, ensuring you wake up feeling refreshed instead of overheated.

Quilted-Cotton Topper

A quilted-cotton topper adds an extra layer of softness and breathability to your mattress. Found in the best medium mattress options, this feature provides gentle cushioning while enhancing airflow to keep you cool during the night. Cotton’s natural ability to wick away moisture helps create a comfortable sleep surface, even in warm weather. A quilted-cotton topper is perfect for anyone who loves a cozy, plush feel without overheating, offering both comfort and practicality.

Gel-Infused Memory Foam

Gel-infused memory foam is a smart choice for the best soft mattress, offering the contouring comfort of traditional memory foam while addressing heat retention. Tiny gel particles are embedded in the foam to pull heat away from your body, helping to keep the surface cool. This material is great for side sleepers who need pressure relief on their shoulders and hips but don’t want to wake up feeling hot. It’s a cool, supportive, and cozy upgrade for any soft mattress.

Open-Cell Latex

Open-cell latex is a great material for the best soft mattress because it combines comfort, durability, and breathability. Its open-cell structure allows air to flow freely, keeping you cool while you sleep. This latex contours to your body to relieve pressure on sensitive areas like your shoulders and hips while bouncing back quickly for easy movement. It’s also naturally hypoallergenic, making it a smart choice for those with allergies or sensitive skin.

Fabric-Encased Pocket Coil

Fabric-encased pocket coils are a key feature in many of the best soft mattresses, providing targeted support and motion isolation. Each coil is individually wrapped, allowing them to move independently and adjust to your body’s shape. This means better support for your spine and less disturbance from a partner’s movements. These coils also promote airflow, helping to keep the mattress cool. It’s the perfect balance of softness and stability for a comfortable night’s rest.

Bear
Check Price

Bear Elite Hybrid

An ultra-luxurious 14-inch mattress with an advanced cooling technology and five zone support coil system.
Check Price

Bear Elite Hybrid

An ultra-luxurious 14-inch mattress with an advanced cooling technology and five zone support coil system.
Check Price

Trustworthiness

When choosing the best soft mattress, trustworthiness is important. Look for brands that are open about their materials and policies, including safety certifications like CertiPUR-US or GREENGUARD. Customer reviews can also give you insight into real experiences with the mattress and how the company handles support or returns.

A trustworthy company offers clear warranties and trial periods, showing they care about your satisfaction. It’s always better to buy from a brand you can rely on to deliver quality and stand by their promises.

Quality Assurance

Budget

Budget is important when choosing the best soft mattress. Mattresses come in a wide range of prices, from budget-friendly options to high-end luxury models. It’s worth considering how much you’re comfortable spending and what features matter most to you, like cooling layers or extra support.

While a more affordable mattress might be tempting, investing in durable materials such as high-density foam or hybrid coils can ensure the mattress lasts longer and provides consistent comfort over time.

Trial

A trial period lets you test the best soft mattress in your own home, so you can decide if it’s the right fit. Most brands offer trial periods between 90 and 120 nights, giving you time to adjust to the feel and see if it relieves pressure or improves your sleep.  If it’s not the right match, a good trial policy allows for an easy return or exchange. This makes trying out a new mattress worry-free, ensuring you’re happy with your choice.

Guarantees

Guarantees can make choosing the best soft mattress easier and stress-free. Many brands offer satisfaction guarantees that let you try the mattress for a set period, giving you time to see if it works for your comfort and support needs. If the mattress doesn’t meet expectations, a clear return or exchange policy ensures you can find a better option. These guarantees show the company’s confidence in their product and put your mind at ease when making a purchase.

Warranty

A warranty protects your investment in the best soft mattress by covering issues like sagging, faulty materials, or manufacturing defects. Most warranties range from 10 years to a lifetime, depending on the brand. Reading the fine print is important to understand what’s included and how to file a claim if needed. A strong warranty is a good sign that the mattress is built to last and provides peace of mind for years of use.

Durability

Durability is important when choosing the best soft mattress to ensure it maintains its comfort and support over time. High-density foam and strong coil systems help prevent sagging and keep the mattress feeling consistent for years. Mattresses with reinforced edges and quality stitching also tend to last longer. A durable mattress not only saves you money in the long run but also ensures you enjoy the same level of comfort night after night.

Puffy
Check Price

Puffy Lux Mattress

A high-performance hybrid mattress that offers a high-quality blend of hyperflex fabric and an advanced coil system.
Check Price

Puffy Lux Mattress

A high-performance hybrid mattress that offers a high-quality blend of hyperflex fabric and an advanced coil system.
Check Price

How We Chose the Best Soft Mattress?

To find the best soft mattress, we focused on the features that matter most for comfort and support. Mattresses with plush foam layers or hybrid designs made the list because they cushion pressure points like shoulders and hips while still offering enough support to prevent discomfort. We also looked for cooling features, like breathable covers and gel-infused foams, to ensure hot sleepers stay comfortable.

Trial periods and warranties were also considered since they provide peace of mind and show the brand’s confidence in their product. Customer reviews helped us understand real-life experiences to confirm each mattress delivers on its promises. This way, we chose mattresses that combine comfort, durability, and value to meet a variety of sleep needs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Medium beds are soft enough to cushion your shoulders to prevent pressure from building up. Soft mattresses offer this as well, but they can sometimes cause heavier sleepers to sink into their beds. Side sleepers can also go with a medium-soft or medium-plush mattress for an in-between feel.

If you sleep on your side, you need a soft mattress to reduce strain on your shoulders and hips. However, it should not be too comfortable because the gravitational force will strain your spine. Most side sleepers will benefit from a medium-soft to medium-firm mattress.

A softer mattress is usually recommended for those who are experiencing back pain on a standard mattress, or those who have pre-existing back problems. They’re also recommended for lighter individuals as a harder mattress can end up not compressing for them at all.

It may take up to 30 days for your body to adjust to a new sleep surface. Sleep trials give you extra time to adjust. Plus, if the mattress feels too hard, a sleep trial allows you to exchange the bed for a softer model.

Side-sleepers put pressure on their shoulders and hips. Look for a mattress with a cushiony top layer to relieve this. Most dedicated side-sleepers will sleep best on a medium-soft to medium mattress. If you shift to your back or stomach, you may prefer a firmer bed.

A high-quality plush mattress should last just as long as its firmer counterparts, so roughly about 7 to 10 years. But beware, some low-quality plush mattresses lose their bounce and cushioning sooner than firm mattresses.

One of the most popular suggestions to make your mattress firmer is to add plywood or an MDF sheet underneath your mattress. This is because the solid, even surface will make it feel more supportive. It will also prevent the mattress from dipping and sagging as quickly.

Sleeping on the wrong mattress is one of the most common causes of back pain. A mattress that’s too hard will place excessive pressure on your spine leading to back discomfort. On the other hand, a mattress that’s too soft will not support your spinal curvature. Thus, leading to aches and pains in your back.

One of the largest factors in deciding if you need a firm vs. plush mattress is your preferred sleeping position. Stomach sleepers tend to feel best on a firmer bed, while side sleepers need plush pressure relief. Back sleepers and combination sleepers could be suited for either or prefer a mattress with a medium feel.

If your hand struggles to fit, it means the mattress is too soft. While if your hand passes smoothly, the mattress is too firm. A mattress that is too soft or firm will not allow the spine to maintain its natural curve. As a result, muscle tension and strain will occur over time, creating discomfort and back pain.

Published On: March 3rd, 2025|Last Updated: March 5th, 2025|Categories: Best Mattress, by Sleeping Preferences|33.4 min read|Views: 38|

Share This Post!