When you’re shopping for a mattress, firmness is one of the most important decisions you’ll make. Two of the most popular choices are plush and medium mattresses. But what is the difference between plush and medium mattress, and how do you know which one is right for YOU?

In this guide, I’ll walk you through the real feel of each type, how they affect your body, and who they’re best for. Whether you sleep on your back, side, or stomach, understanding these differences can lead to deeper, better sleep every single night.

Let’s break it down in a way that’s easy to understand and even easier to choose from.

Key Takeaways

  • Plush mattresses offer a soft, cushioned feel, ideal for side sleepers and lighter individuals seeking pressure relief on hips and shoulders.
  • Medium mattresses provide a balance of support and comfort, suitable for back and combination sleepers needing spinal alignment without excessive sinkage.
  • Plush mattresses may lack the necessary support for stomach sleepers and heavier individuals, potentially leading to spinal misalignment.
  • Medium mattresses are versatile, accommodating various sleep positions and body types, making them a popular choice for couples with differing preferences.
  • Choosing between plush and medium mattresses depends on personal comfort preferences, sleep position, and body weight considerations.
what is the difference between plush and medium mattress
AUTHOR

Mattress Advisory

CATEGORY

Mattress Education

POSTED ON

July 2, 2025

What Does Plush Mean In A Mattress?

A plush mattress feels soft, cozy, and almost cloud-like. When you lie down, you’ll notice that you sink into the top layers more deeply. Plush mattresses are built with thicker comfort layers made from materials like memory foam, soft polyfoam, or pillow tops. This design cradles pressure points, especially around your hips and shoulders. That’s why plush beds are often a top pick for side sleepers since they need a softer surface to avoid pressure pain.

However, this extra softness isn’t for everyone. While plush beds offer great comfort, they may lack the support some folks need for proper spine alignment, especially if you’re a heavier sleeper.

What Does Medium Mean In A Mattress?

When shopping for a new bed, you might come across the term “medium mattress” and wonder what does it mean? Simply put, a medium mattress strikes a balance between soft and firm. But what is a medium mattress, really? It offers enough cushion to feel cozy while still providing the support your body needs, especially around your spine.

That’s why it’s often called the “universal comfort” level. But is it good? For many people, yes. It suits a wide range of sleepers, from back sleepers to combination sleepers—and even couples with different preferences.

Side sleepers especially benefit from the pressure relief medium mattresses can offer at the shoulders and hips. If you’re unsure which firmness to choose, medium is usually a safe bet. What does it feel like? Imagine a gentle hug—not too soft, not too firm—just the right balance for a restful night’s sleep.

Key Differences Between Plush And Medium Mattresses

Here are the main ways plush and medium mattresses are different:

  • Firmness Level: Plush = soft and cushy. Medium = balanced and supportive.
  • Feel: Plush sinks more. Medium offers gentle pushback.
  • Support: Medium offers better spinal alignment for more people.
  • Pressure Relief: Plush cushions pressure points more intensely.

Understanding these details can help you avoid picking a mattress that feels amazing at first—but causes backaches later.

Who Should Choose A Plush Mattress?

A plush mattress is ideal for:

  • Side sleepers who need relief at the hips and shoulders.
  • Petite sleepers under 130 lbs who don’t compress firmer mattresses well.
  • People who love a deep, sinking, cozy feel like a pillow top hotel bed.

If you wake up with sore joints or feel like firmer beds are too hard, a plush mattress might just be the upgrade your body’s asking for.

Who Should Choose A Medium Mattress?

Go with a medium mattress if you:

  • Sleep on your back or change positions often at night.
  • Share the bed with a partner and need a firmness that works for both.
  • Want something that offers both softness and support.

Medium mattresses help keep your spine aligned while giving your body a little cushion, perfect for all-around comfort. Still not sure if it’s the right fit? Think about who should sleep on it. These beds are great for people who want versatility—whether you’re a solo sleeper or part of a couple.

They work well for those who don’t have extreme preferences for super-soft or extra-firm beds. If you tend to move around a lot during the night or like sleeping in different positions, a medium mattress can adapt with you. It offers a nice middle ground that suits many body types and sleep styles without compromising on comfort or support.

what is the difference between plush and medium mattress

How Firmness Affects Pressure Relief

The firmness of your mattress plays a big role in how well it relieves pressure throughout your body. It affects how your weight is distributed and how supported you feel during the night. On a plush mattress, your hips and shoulders tend to sink in more, which can help ease pressure on your joints. But if it’s too soft, you might lose that crucial spinal support.

A medium mattress strikes a better balance, offering a gentle cushion while still keeping your spine aligned. This makes it ideal for people who need both comfort and structure.

If your bed feels too soft, you can always add a firmer topper to make it firmer without replacing the entire mattress. Remember, if your mattress isn’t the right firmness for your sleep style, you may wake up stiff or sore even if it felt fine when you first laid down.

Which Mattress Is Best For Back Pain?

Back pain? You want a mattress that keeps your spine in a neutral position. That usually means:

  • Medium firmness is good for back pain sufferers.
  • Plush mattresses only if you’re lightweight and sleep on your side.

Plush beds may feel amazing at first, but if they let your hips sink too far, they can throw off your spine and make back pain worse.

 Plush vs Medium: Pros and Cons

Here’s a quick list comparing plush and medium mattresses:

Plush Mattress Pros

  • Ultra-soft and cozy feel
  • Great for side sleepers
  • Ideal for smaller body types

Plush Mattress Cons

  • May lack long-term support
  • Not great for stomach sleepers
  • Can trap heat if not well-ventilated

Medium Mattress Pros

  • Balanced comfort and support
  • Ideal for back and combo sleepers
  • Good choice for couples

Medium Mattress Cons

  • May feel too firm for some lightweight side sleepers
  • Not as luxurious-feeling as plush beds


While medium mattresses are incredibly versatile, it’s worth considering the disadvantages of a medium mattress. For instance, some people, especially those who prefer an ultra-soft, cradling feel, might find a medium mattress too firm or not plush enough. Lightweight side sleepers may also miss the extra cushioning that a softer bed provides. If you’re someone who loves sinking deeply into your mattress, a plush option may feel more indulgent and cozy.

what is the difference between plush and medium mattress

Mattress Materials That Affect Firmness

It’s not just the label that matters, what’s inside the mattress plays a big role too. Common materials used in plush and medium mattresses include:

  • Memory foam: Often found in plush models for contouring feel.
  • Latex: Naturally bouncy, found in both plush and medium models.
  • Innerspring: Coils provide firm support, topped with soft or medium layers.
  • Hybrid: A mix of foam and springs, available in both plush and medium styles.

A “medium” mattress with latex might feel firmer than a “plush” foam one—even if they’re labeled the same.

Final Thoughts: How To Choose The Right One

Picking between a plush and medium mattress isn’t just about what feels nice, it’s about what truly supports the way you sleep. Start by thinking about your sleep position. Are you a side sleeper who needs more cushioning, or do you sleep on your back and need firmer support? Your body weight also matters, as lighter sleepers often prefer softer surfaces, while heavier sleepers might need something sturdier.

Consider your past mattress experiences. What did you love or hate about them? And don’t forget to factor in any aches or pains you’re hoping to avoid.

Still unsure? Try testing a few in-store if you can, or go with a mattress that offers a generous sleep trial, so you can exchange it if it’s not the right fit.

When in doubt, a medium mattress is usually the safest choice. It offers balanced comfort and works well for a wide range of sleepers.

Frequently Asked Questions

A plush mattress is softer and allows you to sink in more, while a medium mattress offers a balance of softness and support, keeping you more “on top” of the bed.

Generally, yes. Plush mattresses can compress more quickly over time, especially if made from lower-density foams, which may reduce their lifespan.

It can, but only if it’s well-designed. Plush mattresses with quality support layers underneath the softness can still keep your spine aligned.

Often, yes. Plush mattresses tend to hug the body more, which can trap heat, while medium mattresses usually allow for better airflow and less body heat retention.

Not exactly. A pillow-top is a design feature that adds an extra layer of softness, which can be found on both plush and medium mattresses.

 A medium mattress is typically better. It provides more consistent support and resists sagging from extra weight or movement across the bed.

Yes. For example, a plush foam mattress might feel like a deep cradle, while a plush hybrid offers softness with some bounce. Material affects overall feel significantly.

Yes. Because it doesn’t let you sink too deeply, a medium mattress makes it easier to move, shift positions, or get in and out of bed.

Yes. You can use a firm mattress topper or place a bunkie board underneath to increase firmness without buying a new mattress.

In most cases, yes. Medium mattresses offer better flexibility and support for adjustable bases compared to plusher options, which may be too soft or thick to bend easily.

Published On: July 2nd, 2025|Last Updated: July 2nd, 2025|Categories: Mattress Education|8.8 min read|Views: 12|

Share This Post!